6. Report and document
The final report sets out the role definition, the peer group and the reasoning behind it, the data sources, the findings for each pay element and a clear statement of positioning. It is written to be read by boards, auditors and tax advisers, and to be refreshed when the business or the role changes.
What we are seeing
Market data now underpins owner pay decisions
Owners and directors who once set their pay informally now want a market reference before making the decision, not afterwards. Increasingly, the benchmark is commissioned as part of the annual pay-setting process rather than as a one-off exercise.
Discretion alone is no longer enough
An owner may still have the authority to set their own pay, but authority is not evidence. Where pay is challenged, the question is whether it reflects market value for the role. Peer data, documented with a clear method, answers that question; the owner's judgement on its own does not.
Role clarity determines the peer group
In businesses with several owners, each person's role needs to be defined separately. One co-owner may run the business day to day, another may lead a single function, and a third may be largely non-executive. Benchmarking all three against the same chief executive peer group would overstate the market value for some and understate it for others. Clear role definitions are the foundation of a credible benchmark.
Pay mix is under scrutiny
Our benchmarks increasingly look at the structure of pay, not just the total.
Fixed pay should measure up to the market benchmark for the defined role. We regularly see fixed salaries that vary widely among owners, partly because owners have more discretion over how pay is split and some weight their reward heavily towards variable pay.
Variable pay should be tied to reasonable metrics and KPIs, such as financial results or agreed objectives, rather than being a discretionary distribution under another name. Among firms that formalise variable pay, bonus sizing tends to be more consistent than fixed salary.