The most damaging position is the top left: a strong promise that daily life does not match. New joiners notice within weeks, and the disappointment shows up in early resignations. The bottom right is a missed opportunity, where the organisation offers more than it says.
Building an EVP in four steps
1. Listen first
Gather evidence from current employees through survey data, focus groups and stay interviews. Ask what keeps them, what they would tell a friend about working here, and what they would change. Exit data shows what the EVP is failing to deliver.
2. Identify what is distinctive
Most employers offer competitive pay and decent benefits. Look for what is genuinely different: the type of work, the pace of growth, the quality of development, the stability, the people. Two or three distinctive themes are enough.
3. Write it plainly
Describe each theme in language employees would recognise. Avoid generic phrases such as "a great place to work" or "passionate people". If a statement could appear on any company's website, it does not belong in yours.
4. Check it against reality
For each theme, ask what evidence supports it and where it falls short. If you promise development, is there a training budget people actually use? If you promise growth, do people get promoted from within?